Ever wondered how a game store comes up with a trade-in offer?
Let’s break it down with a real-world example so you can see exactly how the process works.
Example Trade-In
Let’s say you bring in the following:
- Nintendo Switch console
- 5 popular games (Mario, Zelda, etc.)
- 3 older Xbox 360 titles
At first glance, that might feel like a big collection—but value depends on the details.
Step 1: Determine Retail Value
We start by looking at what these items typically sell for right now:
- Switch console: ~$250
- 5 Switch games: ~$40 each = $200
- 3 Xbox 360 games: ~$5 each = $15
Estimated retail total: $465
Step 2: Factor in Condition
We check:
- Are the games complete?
- Are there scratches or damage?
- Is the console clean and fully functional?
Let’s assume everything is in good condition—no major deductions.
Step 3: Consider Sell-Through Time
Not everything sells at the same speed.
- Switch items: high demand, quick turnover
- Xbox 360 games: slower, lower demand
This affects how much we can realistically offer.
Step 4: Make a Fair Offer
A typical trade-in offer might land around:
$200–$275 depending on demand and condition
Why not the full $465?
Because we take on:
- The risk of items not selling
- Time and effort to test, clean, and resell
- Business overhead (rent, staff, etc.)
What Makes a Strong Trade-In Offer?
At our store, we focus on:
- Being transparent about how we got the number
- Offering competitive value based on real data
- Giving you cash
How to Maximize Your Trade-In Value
Want to get the most for your games?
- Bring complete copies when possible
- Clean your items beforehand
- Group higher-demand items together
- Ask about store credit bonuses
The Goal: Fair and Honest Deals
We know trading in your collection can feel uncertain.
That’s why we take the time to explain everything clearly—so you know exactly what you’re getting and why.
No pressure. No guesswork. Just straightforward value.
EXCELLENT Based on 48 reviews Posted on Derya TopalTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I’m a big time gamer and I have purchased multiple items from these guys and they have always been amazing. High quality, fair prices and the best shipping times. I’m always satisfied with my purchases. Two large thumbs up from these guys. Buy with absolute confidence. You guys are the bestPosted on Lee GuilleTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Jesse was very communicative and gave me a solid price on the games I sold. This was very easy and I would absolutely work with Save and Reload Games again.Posted on Christian BTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Excellent support aux clients! Produit en bon état et livré selon promesse.Posted on April HTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Product is excellent quality! Prices are more than reasonable. Good selection of games and accessories. Will be doing business again.Posted on Carter LindhardtTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Always love coming to your booth at the Nerd Sale. Fair prices and super friendly and chatty! Thanks for the games and hope to see you again at the next show!Posted on JacobTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Bought two 3DS games online at great prices, and they arrived two days after ordering. Both were fully functioning and had all the advertised items. Highly recommend.Posted on Ally LillyTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. These guys have an excellent selection of games - they were even able to find a very niche request for me at a great price! Rylan was also super friendly and easy to coordinate pickup with. I'll definitely be a repeat customer!Posted on Brady SommerfeldTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Jesse was quick to reply, honest and easy to deal with. I sent a list of items and photos, received a fair quote shortly after, and set up a meet within a few days. Great experience overall, would definitely recommend!
Have a Collection to Trade?
Show us anytime—we’ll take a look and walk you through the process step by step.
You might be surprised what your games are worth.

