The Most Valuable Nintendo 64 Games You Should Look Out For

The Nintendo 64 holds a special place in the hearts of gamers who grew up with it. While you may have fond memories of classics like Super Mario 64 or Mario Kart 64, some games on the console have become highly sought-after collector’s items. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just looking to see if you’re sitting on a hidden gem, this list is for you. Here are some of the most valuable N64 games that every collector in Edmonton—and across Canada—should look out for.

1. ClayFighter: Sculptor's Cut

Why it’s valuable: This fighting game is legendary among collectors for its extreme rarity. It was a Blockbuster Video exclusive rental, meaning it was never sold at retail. Its limited production run and unique distribution method have made it one of the “holy grail” games for the console.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $5,000+ CAD

2. Stunt Racer 64

Why it’s valuable: Another Blockbuster rental exclusive, this futuristic racing game from Midway had a very limited release. Much like ClayFighter, its scarcity is tied directly to its distribution method.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $1,500+ CAD

3. Bomberman 64: The Second Attack!

Why it’s valuable: The sequel to Bomberman 64 sold poorly upon release, which means very few copies are in circulation today. The game itself is a solid action-adventure title, but its low print run is what makes it so valuable.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $1,000+ CAD

4. Worms Armageddon

Why it’s valuable: While the Worms franchise is well-known, its N64 version had a very limited release in North America. This turn-based strategy game has a dedicated following, and the scarcity of physical copies has driven up its price.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $1,000+ CAD

5. Super Bowling

Why it’s valuable: This game is a prime example of a title that failed commercially but found its value in the collector’s market. A full 3D remake of a Super Nintendo title, its poor sales led to a very low print run.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $2,400+ CAD

6. Ogre Battle 64: Person of Lordly Caliber

Why it’s valuable: A complex and well-regarded real-time strategy RPG, this title had a much smaller North American release than in Japan. Its deep gameplay and scarcity have made it a favorite for collectors.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $270+ CAD

7. Goemon's Great Adventure

Why it’s valuable: This quirky 2.5D platformer is the sequel to Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon. While a fan favourite, it had a low print run, and finding a complete copy in good condition is a challenge.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $315+ CAD

8. Conker's Bad Fur Day

Why it’s valuable: Known for its adult humour and cutting-edge graphics for the time, Conker’s Bad Fur Day had limited sales due to a lack of advertising from Nintendo. It has since gained a cult following, making complete copies highly valuable.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $310+ CAD

9. Resident Evil 2

Why it’s valuable: This N64 port of the PlayStation classic is a technical marvel and a must-have for survival horror fans. While the game itself isn’t rare, a complete-in-box copy is hard to come by and highly sought after by collectors.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $190+ CAD

10. Paper Mario

Why it’s valuable: This beloved RPG is a classic and one of the last first-party titles released for the N64. While not as rare as others on this list, its popularity and late release have kept its value consistently high.

Approximate Value (Complete in Box): $220+ CAD

The retro game market is always changing. If you have any of these games sitting in your basement, you could be sitting on a goldmine. As an online video game seller in Edmonton, we at Save and Reload Games are always on the lookout for rare and valuable titles. We offer competitive prices for your retro games and consoles. If you’re looking to start or expand your collection, check out our selection on our website! And remember, we ship Canada-wide!